Kinghorn sewage: water issues are serious but tracing the source is complex

Like many people in Kinghorn, I am frustrated by the ongoing water quality issues affecting the beach.

Residents and visitors have every right to expect clean, safe water, and the current situation is not good enough. Scottish Water must continue to be held accountable, and no-one believes that the contamination concerns around Kinghorn Beach are acceptable.

At the same time, I think it’s important to recognise the scale of the work that has already been undertaken to try to identify and resolve the problem.

This is not a case of an organisation ignoring complaints or failing to act. Investigations have been ongoing for years, involving Scottish Water, SEPA, Fife Council, NHS Fife and the Fife Coast and Countryside Trust.

David Torrance at Kinghorn beach where the water has has been hit with sewage issues (Pic: Contributed)placeholder image
David Torrance at Kinghorn beach where the water has has been hit with sewage issues (Pic: Contributed)

Extensive inspections have been carried out across the sewer and drainage networks, faults have been repaired, cross-connections removed, water quality sampling increased, and public health warnings issued when required.

The reality is that the source of contamination is proving exceptionally difficult to trace. The Lady Burn flows through a complex network of historic underground infrastructure beneath the town, making this a challenging environmental and engineering problem rather than a straightforward fix.

While that does not excuse poor water quality, it does explain why such a considerable amount of investigation has been necessary and why the issue has not yet been fully resolved.

I also believe it is important to keep this situation in perspective. Scottish Water is a publicly owned utility that reinvests its income into maintaining and improving Scotland's water infrastructure.

Compare that with the position in England, where decades of privatisation have coincided with repeated sewage pollution scandals, crumbling infrastructure, enormous debt and billions of pounds paid out to shareholders as companies prioritise financial return over long-term investment.

Kinghorn's beach water quality problems are serious and must be fixed.

However, I don’t see them as evidence that Scotland's public water model has failed; rather, that they highlight a difficult local problem that is receiving sustained attention, within a system that remains far preferable to the broken model operating south of the border.

News you can trust since 1871
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice