Controversial plans for new homes overlooking iconic St Andrews Old Course rejected

Councillors were unanimous in their opposition to the plans for the Fairways, on the Links, which overlooks the Swilken Bridge and the Old Course.

The plans would have seen the demolition of the current house, constructed in the 1960s, and the building of four homes – a mix of three and four storeys in height.

Councillor Tony Miklinski put forward the motion for the rejection of the application, citing concerns over flooding and the design of the houses.

“There is strong policy evidence that says we should follow what SEPA is telling us and not approve development,” he said.

SEPA and Fife Council’s own flood team both objected to the plans over flooding concerns and noted that the homes would be built on land at risk of flooding.

However, council officers, who recommended approval of the plans, said the development was not a “significant risk” and it would not have a major impact on flood levels.

There was also criticism of the design of the houses.

Cllr Miklinski said he was “shocked” when he first saw the pictures of the plans.

“I have real concerns about it,” he said. “It does not fit in.”

He later added: “Is does not fit in with the historic architecture that surrounds the Old Course. This would have a highly detrimental impact on this iconic site.

“The Old Course and the 18th hole is, from a golfing and historic perspective, a world renowned and unique site surrounded by historic buildings. This sticks out.”

Other councillors also raised their concerns about the flooding risks and the look of the buildings.

“I was shocked,” said Cllr Linda Holt.

“It’s the most iconic and famous location in St Andrews and I think this development would be impactful.”

Councillor Brian Thomson, who seconded Cllr Miklinski’s motion, said the issue of flooding on nearby roads was something that was often brought to his attention.

Local response to the plans had been mixed.

In total, 40 letters of objection had been put forward, including one from St Andrews Community Council.

Most of the concerns focused on the design of the buildings, noting that they looked out of character with the area.

However, 18 letters in support of the plans were also submitted, including one from St Andrews Preservation Trust.