Fire service shake up: Decision on changes at Fife stations deferred

A decision on proposed changes to fire stations in Fife has been further delayed.

This week the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service confirmed decisions taken on changes at fire stations across the country, however the future for Fife’s stations remains unknown for now as the service’s Board has deferred deciding on proposed changes in the Kingdom.

A decision on changes in Fife's fire stations has been deferred. (Pic: George McLuskie)placeholder image
A decision on changes in Fife's fire stations has been deferred. (Pic: George McLuskie)

The SFRS Board met on Monday to consider and decide whether the service should proceed with a suite of recommendations developed from the 23 options for change consulted on during 2025.

Their decisions followed an extensive nationwide Service Delivery Review as part of continuing work to modernise the service and ensure operational resources are matched to changing risk and demand.

In Fife the fire service was looking to make permanent the changes it introduced in 2023. It included a proposal to cut the number of appliances at Lochgelly and Methil fire stations from two to just one each – the second appliance at Methil was one of the those temporarily withdrawn in the last shake up.

The service also proposed re-instating the second appliance it took out of Glenrothes in 2023.

Proposals also included Lochgelly losing its specialist rope rescue capability, which is one of only four such units in Scotland.

The proposed changes in Lochgelly faced an incredible backlash from the public with more than 3000 people signing a petition opposing any reduction in cover from this station.

However, following the fire service’s announcement on the changes this week, only one proposal for change has currently been confirmed in Fife.

The combined aerial rescue pump (CARP) at Dunfermline will be permanently replaced with a dedicated high reach appliance (HRA). This change has been in place temporarily since 2023.

The service said a decision on the appliance configuration in Fife has been deferred “subject to further analysis”.

The deferral is to allow “further consideration of an alternative proposal to permanently implement the current temporary wholetime pump withdrawal configuration”. This configuration reduced the number of wholetime appliances at Glenrothes and Methil from two to one.

The service said this existing arrangement – which has second pumps temporarily withdrawn from Glenrothes and Methil – is to continue until further notice.

Mhairi Wylie, Chair of the Board, said: “The Service Delivery Review is about ensuring that resources across Scotland are used to best meet risk and demand, ensuring parity and fairness across communities.

“We recognise the strength of feeling that exists in some communities. As a Board, we take this extremely seriously and the public consultation has been invaluable in shaping the recommendations and decisions.

“There are some options that we will not be proceeding with, and others will be deferred to explore further arrangements.

“We have listened to the concerns raised, and we will continue to closely monitor the impact of any changes.

“These decisions have been taken with community safety and firefighter safety as the primary considerations, while delivering best value for the people of Scotland.

“We believe these changes are transparent, evidence-led, legally robust and operationally deliverable. They will ensure the Service continues to be a leading exemplar of public sector reform.”

Following the board’s decision this week, Glenrothes and Mid Fife MP Richard Baker, said: “I’m relieved the SFRS board came to the only right decision in my mind, which was to leave Lochgelly’s existing fire services untouched. However, there’s a caveat involved.

"The board decided that, given communities in Methil and Glenrothes had not been consulted on the new option three – which was to leave Lochgelly with two pumps – this would legally require the SFRS to go back and consult again in those areas.

"We’ve got a deferral for the time being and that’s thanks to the amazing campaign led by Lochgelly’s firefighters and the local community, including Lochgelly Community Council. They should feel very proud, as am I for backing the community and the campaign since day one.

"Everyone was aware of the high stakes involved. The removal of an appliance would leave the community exposed to unacceptable risk and would certainly have meant the loss of the highly-trained rope rescue unit.

"I believe fire chiefs need to put back an appliance taken away from Glenrothes or Methil in 2023, but not at the expense of Lochgelly.

"At the start of the SDR consultation last year, I’m certain the SFRS didn’t have a clue how formidable the people of Lochgelly can be when they put up a fight. They do now, and I’m hoping that just might be enough to make them think twice about ever coming back with similar proposals to cut in future. Let’s hope so."

The public consultation ran for a period of 12 weeks and closed in September 2025. This involved 40 public events across Scotland and received more than 3,600 responses.

News you can trust since 1871
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice