New Fife MSP hits back in ‘two jobs’ spat with Labour councillor
A newly elected Fife MSP has hit back after a fellow councillor called for him to resign from his position on Fife Council.
Labour councillor Patrick Browne posted on social media saying it was time for the new “two jobbing” David Barratt - who won the Cowdenbeath seat at last week’s elections - to step back from his duties on the local authority.
Both councillors represent the Inverkeithing and Dalgety Bay ward and Cllr Browne said last week’s results had raised an “immediate issue.”
He stated: “The people of Inverkeithing and Dalgety Bay need a full-time councillor in addition to a full-time MSP, on that basis Cllr Barratt should stand down from his role as a councillor and let the public pick a new councillor to represent them on Fife Council.


“It isn’t possible to combine the role of an MSP with that of a councillor, especially when you are covering multiple wards as an MSP at the same time representing one ward as a councillor.
“It is just a matter of time until those issues conflict especially when he is convener of the area committee and planning committee.
“So our new ‘two jobbing’ MSP should resign his council seat, call a by-election and allow someone else the opportunity to serve.”
Cllr Barratt said he planned to continue as a councillor - a stance also taken by Councillor Julie MacDougall was was one of two ReformUK list candidates to become MSPs.
He said a by-election would be costly and added: “I will be stepping back from a number of key roles within Fife Council to help manage the additional demands on my time, and I have already been discussing this with colleagues. What I will not be stepping back from is being an active ward councillor. I care passionately about ward six and if I thought for a moment I could not do the role justice, I would resign.
“For context, the Scottish Parliament agreed new dual-mandate rules towards the end of the last parliamentary term. These prohibit MSPs from continuing as councillors unless a council election is due within one year which is the case here.”
Cllr Barratt stressed there were no financial benefits to carrying out both roles.
“A councillor’s salary is deducted from MSP salary, reducing cost to the public purse,” he added. “I also sought advice on the cost of triggering a by-election and was advised it would likely cost around £60,000.
“I do not believe that would be in the public interest barely a year before scheduled council elections, even if it might be the easier route personally.”