'It wasn't a foul': St Andrews United boss Greg Shields hits out at ref's disallowed goal call

St Andrews United gaffer Greg Shields has disputed a controversial refereeing decision to disallow a Saints ‘goal’ in last weekend’s 1-0 home South Challenge Cup fourth round encounter against Rutherglen Glencairn.

With Saints trailing to Ross Paton’s 20th-minute ‘wonder strike’ from 30 yards, defender Jason Thomson thought he’d levelled with 10 minutes left but the effort was chalked off as team-mate Scott Dunn was adjudged to have fouled visiting goalkeeper Jamie Smith before Thomson’s shot.

“I don't think it was a foul by Scott,” boss Shields told the Herald and Citizen. “I don't know, but these things happen.

"The referees sometimes make calls that they look back on and they think maybe it was a mistake.

St Andrews United boss Greg Shields was frustrated by one or two refereeing decisions during last weekend's cup defeat (Pic Scott Louden)placeholder image
St Andrews United boss Greg Shields was frustrated by one or two refereeing decisions during last weekend's cup defeat (Pic Scott Louden)

"But you've just got to adapt and go on with it. There's plenty of time left in the game to score.

"There's always controversy over refereeing decisions.

"But over the course of the game, I thought it was fairly even to be honest. I don't think we played particularly well.

"I'd like to have created more chances and been more fluent going forward. We weren't, which was disappointing. But on to the weekend now.”

On the performance of debutant goalkeeper Thomas Margetts, who has arrived on loan from Dunfermline Athletic, Shields said: “He did well, he's a young boy, 16.

"Coming from Dunfermline, I've known him in the past, having coached him a few years ago when I was there.

"And obviously coming here is great for his development, coming to a men's team and learning his trade here. So, it's a good opportunity for him.”

United also had to play the last few minutes against Glencairn – who play their trade in the West of Scotland Football League Premier Division – with 10 men as Dunn was dismissed for mouthing at the referee.

Shields added: “I think the referee was right to send Scott off after what he obviously said to the referee.

"So, I spoke to Scott about it and it's one of those things. You get caught up in frustration, you say things at the wrong time and you get punished for it.

"So he knows what he's done and we move on.”

After the disappointment of their cup exit last weekend, United’s attention turns back to life in the East of Scotland Football League Premier Division.

Shields’ men go into this Saturday’s away game against Bo’ness Athletic, which kicks off at 2.30pm, sitting ninth in the table having accumulated 17 points from their 14 fixtures.

Saturday’s match represents the first time that Willie Irvine’s Athletic side will have taken on St Andrews since beating a beleaguered Saints 9-0 away from home in a first round Alex Jack Cup tie way back on August 7, 2021.

Shields said: “I always think they're all tough games. They're never easy.

"It depends on whether or not you take your opportunities in the games.

"If you do, you can go and win by two or three.

"If you don’t, you can then easily lose one or two goals.

"We've had a bad run recently. We've lost by the odd goal apart from Musselburgh in the last six or seven games.

"But it's just who wants it more in the day and what decisions go for you and fall for you.

"If you dominate the game, you win. If you don't and you don't take your chances, you don't get a result.

"And that's been fairly evident over the last four or five weeks.

" So we've got to respond. It's a big game for us.

"We want to get back on track.

"We'll obviously approach it like every other game and our mindset will be on the win.”

News you can trust since 1871
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice